5 min readVersion 1.0Last reviewed
General information, not advice about your specific transfer.
Two providers quote you for the same tuition payment. One charges a fee. The other says "no fees". The one with no fees can still be the more expensive choice, and most people never find out.
That's because the fee is only one of four places a transfer can cost you.
Four places the cost can sit
| Where | What it is | Do you see it upfront? |
|---|---|---|
| Sending fee | A flat or percentage charge from the bank or provider you pay | Usually |
| Exchange rate margin | The gap between the market rate and the rate you're given | Rarely spelled out |
| Intermediary fees | Charges taken out of the payment by banks along the route | Often not |
| Receiving fee | A charge from the receiving bank to credit the money | Often not |
Only the first is usually printed as a "fee". The other three show up as less money arriving.
The rate is usually the biggest cost
Most providers don't convert your money at the market rate. They use a slightly worse rate and keep the difference. That difference is called the margin or spread. If you want to know what the market rate is and why it keeps moving, read "Rates: Mid-Market, Spot, and Why the Number Keeps Moving".
A margin isn't wrong. Converting money costs something to provide. The problem is when it hides behind a "no fee" headline, so you can't compare like for like.
Small percentage, big number
A margin of 2 or 3% sounds small. On a tuition payment it isn't.
Here's an illustrative example. The rates are round numbers to make the maths easy, not today's rates.
- A family in India sends ₹2,000,000 for tuition in Canada.
- The mid-market rate is ₹62 to C$1. At that rate, the payment is worth C$32,258.
- Provider A charges no fee but uses a rate 2.5% worse: ₹63.55 to C$1. The university receives C$31,471.
- That's C$787 gone, with no line on the receipt that says "fee".
Provider B might charge a visible fee and use a rate much closer to the market, and still deliver more Canadian dollars. You only know by comparing what arrives.
How to compare two quotes properly
Ask each provider one question: how much will arrive, in the currency it arrives in? Then:
- Get both quotes at the same time. Rates move, and a quote is usually only held for a short while.
- Check the mid-market rate at that same moment, and convert the amount you're sending at that rate. That's what the money is really worth.
- Subtract the amount each provider says will arrive.
- The difference is your total cost: fees and margin together.
The quote that delivers the most money for the same amount sent is the cheaper one, however the cost is labelled.
Watch for the top-up
With bank transfers, intermediary fees can mean tuition arrives a little short, and you're left topping up the balance. Bank transfer forms often carry a charges option for this:
| Code | Who pays the charges |
|---|---|
| OUR | The sender pays all charges, so the full amount should arrive |
| SHA | Charges are shared. Banks along the way may deduct theirs from the payment |
| BEN | The receiver pays. Charges come out of the amount that arrives |
For tuition, ask whether the amount received is guaranteed. If it isn't, find out how short it could be before you send.
Phrases to read twice
| What it says | What to check |
|---|---|
| "Zero fees" or "fee-free" | What rate are they using compared with the market rate? |
| "Bank rate" or "our rate" | How far is it from the market rate, in percent? |
| "Estimated" amount received | Can it change after you send? Who pays if it does? |
| "Fees may be deducted by intermediary banks" | How much might arrive short, and will you have to top it up? |
The short version
A transfer's real cost is the fee, plus the margin in the rate, plus anything taken along the way. Compare what arrives, not the fee headline. A provider that tells you plainly what will land is making it easy for you to check.
What readers made of this
Not rated yetSign in to rate this article and join the discussion
Sign inDiscussion(0)
Sign in with your TBX Academy account to read and join the discussion.